5 Reason Why Vin Scully is Terrible

8 Mar

vin scullyVin Scully is one of the most revered and treasured announcers of all time in baseball history. He captivated radio and television audiences as the lone announcer for the Dodgers for 50+ years, but for the last 10 years he has shown a noticeable decline in performance. However, the baseball community has praised this man’s ability to announce a baseball game to no end. This is a man so beloved that not even the Roastmaster General Jeff Ross will even touch this legend. That’s ok Jeff, I’ll step in for you on this one. Here are 5 reasons why Vin Scully is terrible at announcing baseball games:


He has forgotten more about baseball than the vast majority of the public will ever know. And do you know why he has forgotten? Because he is too old to still be living, let alone be allowed to announce baseball games. Here’s a picture of Vin and Larry King sharing a foxhole in WW1.


Do you know what the prerequisites was to be an announcer when he started in the 1950’s? Neither do I. Neither does anyone, because everyone that did know is dead by now. More than likely it took a penis and a voice people found pleasant enough to listen to for three hours. It is true that I bleed Giants orange and may be biased against the Dodgers announcer, but even unbiased fans of the game would most likely put the TV on mute while watching a game that he announces. There is a reason every other ball club has a two-man crew announcing the game: no one wants to hear the same fucking voice and extraordinarily biased opinion for 3 hours.

Lost Touch of Priorities

Dodger fans might say that he has the most random details about player’s lives…I’ll give him that much credit. He has forgotten more about baseball history than I will ever know and he has interesting tidbits about the lives of players. Unfortunately, he would rather tell stories than focus on the game. He has the old man mental capacity for exactly one story per player in baseball, which means every game I hear the same exact story.  Thank you for the inside information about Ryan Theriot’s family parrot; that was an entertaining story…when you told it the first five times on the last Giants home stand.

Unparallel Bias

Announcers have an obligation to call the game with impartial disposition. There is not a more biased and opinionated announcer in sports today. I’ll give you an example of what you might hear on a standard game:

“And here comes baseball’s best player Matt Kemp to the plate. Not only is Kemp an amazing three sport athlete in high school, he is also an exemplarily human being, who last week donated two million dollars of his own salary and numerous hours of charity work to the Boys and Girls Club. Truly a man that any youngster can look up to and strive to be…and pitching to him today is Tim Lincecum, who once was charged with the crime of raping and murdering his own grandmother in order to collect life insurance money to pay off a bookie for his extensive debt in puppy fighting losses. He was later exonerated of all charges due to mishandling of evidence, which some people believe had to do with Buster Posey’s connections with the FBI….and here’s the pitch…called strike one by the umpire, but Kemp doesn’t agree with the call, and neither do I, as that ball looked to be a foot outside from my vantage point of the third deck with 90 year old eyes.”

Changing Times for the Dodgers

Magic Johnson and company are counting down the days until this guy dies, which will inevitably be via choking on his own verbal diarrhea. There is not even a glimmer of a chance this guy will retire. I’m relatively sure he is currently propped up on his death bed inside the announcing booth, taking shots some elixir that Jack Lalain sold him back in the 50’s. The Juicemaster himself is rolling in his grave at the fact that Vin outlasted him with a diet of Dodger dogs, Budweiser, and tears of children.


Vin Scully is a living legend and he should be revered as the icon he is in baseball history, but his time in the booth should be stopped immediately for everyone’s sake. It is time for the Dodgers to step up and force him to retire before he dies in the booth.

16 thoughts on “5 Reason Why Vin Scully is Terrible

  1. If he doesn’t die from choking on his own verbal diarrhea, I will volunteer to choke him to death. The worst part about it is that other announcers try to tell me how great he is but when I listen to him, I find myself yelling at him and not paying attention to the game. In a weird way I guess the Dodgers deserve him. That is, when you suck as bad as the Dodgers do, you might as well have an announcer that sucks too.

    • Don’t use violence Myk, we wouldn’t want to stoop to the Dodger fan level. I put the TV on mute, I cannot handle him. I agree that the Dodgers deserve him; it’s ony a matter of time until they start agreeing with me on this and stop defending him. Thanks for the comment!

  2. While reading this post, I unmuted the Cardinals/Dodgers game to hear Vin Scully talk about B17 bombers flying over Germany for a good minute as a pitch or two went by. Was he having a flashback? I don’t know. I thought the station was streaming audio from the History Channel.

    • That’s a perfect example JD. The first hand stories are great, he is a living history lesson with a microphone and an audience that has no other option for an announcer. Update – he signed on for 2016. You deserve him Dodgers fans!

  3. Spoken in a monotone drone: “Stepping up to the plate is Jimmy Jones. Jones is batting .265 but in his last 37 at bats he’s batting only .264. Jones grew up in Podunkville, Arkansas, where he was an excellent student, although his grades for penmanship fell below the B level. His third grade teacher, Mrs. Mabel Granville wore size 7 shoes, but when she herself was in the third grade, she only wore a size four. Jones wears a size 11, giving him the 16th largest shoe size among major league center fielders. Or at least he does on his left foot. His right foot is actually only a 10 and a half. And it looks like he flied out to center a few minutes ago. I guess I must have missed it, but you have to admit, shoes can be pretty fascinating.”

  4. Why are you guys hating on him so much? It’s actually pretty pathetic because you guys have nothing else to do but hate on one of the most memorable faces of baseball. The guy has broadcasted so many World Series’ and always gives a story on the players and the team and a ton of other things. Almost all the fans and players love him except you haters. Now tell why he isn’t the best broadcaster and who’s better. The answer is that he is the best broadcaster ever and that not a single broadcaster is better than him.

  5. Hi blogger, i must say you have very interesting posts here.

    Your website can go viral. You need initial traffic only.
    How to get it? Search for: make your content go viral Wrastain’s tools

  6. I’ve been surfing online more than three hours today, yet
    I never found any interesting article like yours. It is pretty worth enough for me.
    In my view, if all website owners and bloggers made good content as you did, the net will be a lot more useful than ever before.

  7. Hi there to every body, it’s my first visit of this webpage; this webpage consists
    of awesome and really good data designed for visitors.

  8. It’s really a nice and helpful piece of information. I am satisfied that
    you simply shared this helpful info with us. Please keep us
    up to date like this. Thanks for sharing.

  9. Just desire to say your article is as astounding. The clearness in your post
    is simply cool and i can assume you are an expert on this subject.
    Fine with your permission allow me to grab your RSS feed to keep updated
    with forthcoming post. Thanks a million and please continue the enjoyable

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.